Nick's Collingwood Bulletin Board

Mr Miyagi wrote:How the **** does Hawthorn get Scully for pick 53? I'm hearing some people at the Dees are fuming.

Get Beams if he's cheap, but if it's a first rounder, not worth it.

is GWS run by the AFL or is it a private club. If its run by the AFL, this should trigger some kind of investigation...... heads should roll for this. its a joke.

Who cares if we pay 'overs'? We're gunning for a premiership RIGHT NOW. Draft picks are for the future, our future is now.

Wokko wrote:Who cares if we pay 'overs'? We're gunning for a premiership RIGHT NOW. Draft picks are for the future, our future is now.

If he comes back, will you change your profile pic?

Pies4shaw wrote:

Wokko wrote:Who cares if we pay 'overs'? We're gunning for a premiership RIGHT NOW. Draft picks are for the future, our future is now.

If he comes back, will you change your profile pic?

I've got this one ready to go

Nice.

He certainly seems committed to coming back to us....

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-15/b ... fits-lions

Just smacks of opportunism to me - he's in the final stages of his career and wants another shot at a premiership.

Do we want players who can't be fussed whether they're at their current club or with us? No. No we don't.

He seemed very casual about it when asked. If a trade can be done, he's happy to go to Collingwood. But if a trade can't be done, he's happy to play on with Brisbane. So yeah, whatever mate, it's up to the clubs, I'm happy wherever.

Sorry Beams, but we don't want 50/50 players at the club. You're either on the bus, or you're not.

I hope Collingwood doesn't stuff up it's Quaynor and Kelly picks trying to get Beams.

I wouldnt have an issue with pick 18 and our first round next year going ther but only if we get multiple 2018 2nd and 3rd rnd selections as part of the deal so we have the points for the father son and academy picks this year

The nagging question i have is who would we have to move on this year and next year to accommodate it.

I dont really want to see Broomhead delisted (he lives with grundy so lets keep him so brodie isnt lonely!!) and it worries me that fringe players may also go like greenwood and goldsack. Not stars but good role players.

bucking awesome wrote:I wouldnt have an issue with pick 18 and our first round next year going ther but only if we get multiple 2018 2nd and 3rd rnd selections as part of the deal so we have the points for the father son and academy picks this year

The nagging question i have is who would we have to move on this year and next year to accommodate it.

I dont really want to see Broomhead delisted (he lives with grundy so lets keep him so brodie isnt lonely!!) and it worries me that fringe players may also go like greenwood and goldsack. Not stars but good role players.

I would. Two first rounders for a 29yo? Crazy.

mabo wrote:He certainly seems committed to coming back to us....

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-15/b ... fits-lions

Just smacks of opportunism to me - he's in the final stages of his career and wants another shot at a premiership.

Nope ...it's called power of the P#55y
The GF

Pick 18 on it's own should get it done IMO. If they are asking too much more than that, then I'm skeptical that it's worth it.

Two first Rounders for a player and their second rounder + Treloar was the Treloar deal. Treloar had 7-8 years in him.

A first rounder + a second rounder, is nearly the same price for Beams, with only 3 years of footy left in him and has been injury prone since at Brisbane. Had a good year in 2018, granted.

If pick 18 can't get it done, then walk away. It's not value.

From SEN Collingwood have made an offer of 18 and future second round for Dayne Beams.