1st Elimination Final - Richmond vs Collingwood
Moderator: bbmods
- MightyMagpie
- Posts: 3450
- Joined: Tue Jun 04, 2013 6:49 pm
- Location: WA
- MagpieBat
- Posts: 17846
- Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2010 2:05 pm
- Location: Brooding in a cave... somewhere... maybe...
1). You could try the "Footy Live" app. They're the mob who do the stats and they do collect season averages and game by game for all the major stats for the AFL listed players. Alternatively, you can manually go searching on the VFL website for the player you're after.
2). There actually is a rule for that scenario. It was an amendment introduced for last year's finals series to deal with the AFL's pre-finals bye. The new rule states that clubs in the situation Richmond are in this week can field anyone who didn't play AFL yesterday. Seeing as they only have 1 man in the injury list, that is a LOT of AFL-listed Tigers...
2). There actually is a rule for that scenario. It was an amendment introduced for last year's finals series to deal with the AFL's pre-finals bye. The new rule states that clubs in the situation Richmond are in this week can field anyone who didn't play AFL yesterday. Seeing as they only have 1 man in the injury list, that is a LOT of AFL-listed Tigers...
I am vengeance. I am the night. I am MagpieBat.
- barrackers
- Posts: 632
- Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2017 10:19 pm
It actually makes very little difference to who's eligible and who isn't for Richmond, although unlike us they won't spell players or put them in for surgery due to the season ending.MagpieBat wrote:1). You could try the "Footy Live" app. They're the mob who do the stats and they do collect season averages and game by game for all the major stats for the AFL listed players. Alternatively, you can manually go searching on the VFL website for the player you're after.
2). There actually is a rule for that scenario. It was an amendment introduced for last year's finals series to deal with the AFL's pre-finals bye. The new rule states that clubs in the situation Richmond are in this week can field anyone who didn't play AFL yesterday. Seeing as they only have 1 man in the injury list, that is a LOT of AFL-listed Tigers...
Effect of that rule:
Short and Caddy would have been ineligible having played too many AFL matches, but are now eligible owing to them missing AFL selection last week. Caddy missed with a hamstring and it's highly unlikely he plays VFL. Short was dropped for form and has played the last 4 VFL games.
Last edited by barrackers on Wed Aug 30, 2017 8:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- barrackers
- Posts: 632
- Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2017 10:19 pm
Our only clash for points in 2017 seen us win away 14.20 104 vs 16.6 102.
Collingwood
Goal Kickers: T. Phillips 3, K. Kirby 2, M. Cox 2, J. White 2, M. Lynch, L. Tardrew, C. Mayne, L. Keeffe, C. Brown
Best Players: T. Phillips, M. Cox, G. Borthwick, J. Ramsay, J. Smith, C. Brown
Richmond
Goal Kickers: T. Stengle 4, T. Hunt 3, J. Townsend 2, T. Elton 2, T. Silvestro, B. Lennon, S. Lloyd, B. Wood, S. Bolton
Best Players: T. Hunt, J. Townsend, I. Maric, J. Ballard, T. Stengle, D. Coffield
LINEUPS
Collingwood
Beveridge, Borthwick, Brown, Close, Cox, Daicos, Hellier, Hinkley, Hore, Keeffe, Kirby, LaFontaine, Lane, Lynch, Mayne, McLarty, Ramsay, Schade, M. Smith, Tardrew, White
Ineligible for final - Phillips, J. Smith
Richmond
Aarts, Bachelor, Ballard, Beasley, Bolton, Chol, Coffield, Elton, Fletcher, Garthwaite, Griffiths, Hunt, Lennon, Lloyd, Mannagh, Maric, Markov, Menadue, Moore, Silvestro, Stengle, Townsend, Wood
DID NOT PLAY - ELIGIBLE FOR FINAL
Collingwood
Aish, Jar. Blair, Crocker, Mackie, Scharenberg, Sier, Thomas, Wills
Richmond
Caddy, Conca, C. Ellis, Hampson, Miles, Morris, Short, Soldo
Collingwood
Goal Kickers: T. Phillips 3, K. Kirby 2, M. Cox 2, J. White 2, M. Lynch, L. Tardrew, C. Mayne, L. Keeffe, C. Brown
Best Players: T. Phillips, M. Cox, G. Borthwick, J. Ramsay, J. Smith, C. Brown
Richmond
Goal Kickers: T. Stengle 4, T. Hunt 3, J. Townsend 2, T. Elton 2, T. Silvestro, B. Lennon, S. Lloyd, B. Wood, S. Bolton
Best Players: T. Hunt, J. Townsend, I. Maric, J. Ballard, T. Stengle, D. Coffield
LINEUPS
Collingwood
Beveridge, Borthwick, Brown, Close, Cox, Daicos, Hellier, Hinkley, Hore, Keeffe, Kirby, LaFontaine, Lane, Lynch, Mayne, McLarty, Ramsay, Schade, M. Smith, Tardrew, White
Ineligible for final - Phillips, J. Smith
Richmond
Aarts, Bachelor, Ballard, Beasley, Bolton, Chol, Coffield, Elton, Fletcher, Garthwaite, Griffiths, Hunt, Lennon, Lloyd, Mannagh, Maric, Markov, Menadue, Moore, Silvestro, Stengle, Townsend, Wood
DID NOT PLAY - ELIGIBLE FOR FINAL
Collingwood
Aish, Jar. Blair, Crocker, Mackie, Scharenberg, Sier, Thomas, Wills
Richmond
Caddy, Conca, C. Ellis, Hampson, Miles, Morris, Short, Soldo
Last edited by barrackers on Wed Aug 30, 2017 8:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- MagpieBat
- Posts: 17846
- Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2010 2:05 pm
- Location: Brooding in a cave... somewhere... maybe...
I was going to look at this, but you've done it quite splendidly, as always.barrackers wrote:Our only clash for points in 2017 seen us win away 14.20 104 vs 16.6 102.
Collingwood
Goal Kickers: T. Phillips 3, K. Kirby 2, M. Cox 2, J. White 2, M. Lynch, L. Tardrew, C. Mayne, L. Keeffe, C. Brown
Best Players: T. Phillips, M. Cox, G. Borthwick, J. Ramsay, J. Smith, C. Brown
Richmond
Goal Kickers: T. Stengle 4, T. Hunt 3, J. Townsend 2, T. Elton 2, T. Silvestro, B. Lennon, S. Lloyd, B. Wood, S. Bolton
Best Players: T. Hunt, J. Townsend, I. Maric, J. Ballard, T. Stengle, D. Coffield
LINEUPS
Collingwood
Beveridge, Borthwick, Brown, Close, Cox, Daicos, Hellier, Hinkley, Hore, Keeffe, Kirby, LaFontaine, Lane, Lynch, Mayne, McLarty, Ramsay, Schade, M. Smith, Tardrew, White
Ineligible for final - Phillips, J. Smith
Richmond
Aarts, Bachelor, Ballard, Beasley, Bolton, Chol, Coffield, Elton, Fletcher, Garthwaite, Griffiths, Hunt, Lennon, Lloyd, Mannagh, Maric, Menadue, Moore, Silvestro, Stengle, Wood
Ineligible for final - Townsend, Markov
DID NOT PLAY - ELIGIBLE FOR FINAL
Collingwood
Aish, Jar. Blair, Crocker, Mackie, Scharenberg, Sier, Thomas, Wills
Richmond
Caddy, Conca, C. Ellis, Hampson, Miles, Morris, Short, Soldo
I am vengeance. I am the night. I am MagpieBat.
- MightyMagpie
- Posts: 3450
- Joined: Tue Jun 04, 2013 6:49 pm
- Location: WA
- MagpieBat
- Posts: 17846
- Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2010 2:05 pm
- Location: Brooding in a cave... somewhere... maybe...
- Collingwood Crackerjack
- Posts: 3567
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2008 10:11 am
- Location: Canberra
All this indeed, plus the fact it would be great to send out White with a bit of sorely deserved silverwareqldmagpie67 wrote:Cheers for that MB
Couple quick things
I think it's vital for there development that Brown Kirby Daicos Cox Schade Aish Ramsay Wills that the coaches put them under extreme pressure and let them know there expected to really dominate the finals series to advance there chances of senior footy in 2018
I think Daicos and Brown showed they are going to be good players when there bodies develop they have the skills and courage just lack size and timing
Cox should be full of confidence and be a handful
Good luck to the boys and MB if things look to be going pear shape during the game I expect you to take over the coaching reigns
- Collingwood Crackerjack
- Posts: 3567
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2008 10:11 am
- Location: Canberra
I'm inclined to disagree, I think a good final series would do him the world of good, with the caveat of course being that the physios think he is right to go physically.E wrote:i just dont think there is any point in playing scharenberg. Put the ferrari back in the garage until next year. no upside here.
We have a good team that can really give it a go, and I reckon we can make the prelim at least, and from there, who knows?
- MightyMagpie
- Posts: 3450
- Joined: Tue Jun 04, 2013 6:49 pm
- Location: WA
Thanks barrackers. I've not seen as much VFL as I would like this year with the reduced streaming coverage, but my impression is that we will have a pretty strong lineup and we seem to have been playing better towards the end of the season.
Looking forward to this Saturday (no AFL footy to compete with either) and hopefully we can knock them off.
Looking forward to this Saturday (no AFL footy to compete with either) and hopefully we can knock them off.
All We Can Be
- barrackers
- Posts: 632
- Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2017 10:19 pm
If we don't spell too many we should field a stronger lineup than last time we met Richmond. While the margin then was just 2 points we dominated that game and should have smashed them. The worrying thing is Richmond will be much stronger this time around with their ins looking greater than ours.MightyMagpie wrote:Thanks barrackers. I've not seen as much VFL as I would like this year with the reduced streaming coverage, but my impression is that we will have a pretty strong lineup and we seem to have been playing better towards the end of the season.
Looking forward to this Saturday (no AFL footy to compete with either) and hopefully we can knock them off.