GB votes v. Melbourne

[Sultan of spin]

3. Nick Maxwell
2. Harry O'Brien
1. Dayne Beams

pls tell me your tongue is firmly planted in your cheek....
worst performance of maxy's career & harry wasnt much better

Maxwell is the most overrated player in this clubs history, he was shit house today and for 3 quarters of last week. He had a standout year last season playing the Jason cloke loose hb role, already seeing players make him more accountable and he struggles 1v1 also turns it over when under pressure.

Anyone who has him in the bests today is either related or blinded by the lil c next to his name.

3. Pendles
2. Beams
1. Reid

* Reid was our best defender spoilt well didn't turn the ball over and the only time he was beaten was when Maxwell cut him off and Maxwell missed the spoil.

Possibly the dumbest comment Ive ever seen, prob shouldnt draw attention to it but hey im pissed!

First of all calling the club captain and all aust player overrated is moronic, hes a genuine gun

second in reference too my first point he hasnt always been a gun and had many shockers to begin his career todays game isnt even close to his worst, that said I thought he played ok and was actually better than he was last week

Third I agree Reid played a decent game and stood up at important times, so glad he got the experience

Fourth Harry was good, not as good as last week but still had a decent game

[john b]

3 Beams
2 Thomas
1 Pendles

Well done to Melbourne, all our top line players didn't play well because Melbourne applied good pressure, accept D...........

[RICHO1991]

3. Beams
2. Pendlebury
1. Thomas

only players that played well on the day too many passengers

[gavin]

beams 1
no other vote deserved sorry

[blackandwhite4life]

3 Pendles
2 Beams
1 Sidebottom

Thomas the only other one that played up to the required standard. (and Reid)

[favourites 2008]

3. Pendles (easily our best imo)
2. Beams
1. Thomas

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

very hard to give the votes this week

3 Davis - 125 supercoach points from 13 possessions and the winning goal
2 Beams
1 BJ

[jack_spain]

very hard to give the votes this week

3 Davis - 125 supercoach points from 13 possessions and the winning goal
2 Beams
1 BJ

Shows what a crock that Supercoach game is. No wonder I don't go in for it.

Apart from the winning goal, what else did Leon do with his touches?

[die4pies]

3. Pendlebury
2. Beams
1. Reid

[ronrat]

Beams. Had to stand up when others failed him
Thomas. Kept us in it early and kept trying.
Pendles. Another let down by piss poor forward work of others.

[talwin]

3- sidebottom
2-pendles
1- thomas

all young midfielders... future is still bright

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

very hard to give the votes this week

3 Davis - 125 supercoach points from 13 possessions and the winning goal
2 Beams
1 BJ

Shows what a crock that Supercoach game is. No wonder I don't go in for it.

Apart from the winning goal, what else did Leon do with his touches?

12 contested possessions, 1 uncontested at 85% efficiency. 2 goals 1 point, 1 goal assist, 1 point assist, 3 clearances, 3 inside 50s, oh...and 7 tackles. back to your hole now fool.

[Cuthbert Collingwood]

and Jack, the winning goal won us the game - that's what a winning goal is. It's worth 4 points to us and is recorded as a win. But I think you may have had a lot more fun on Nick's this week if we had have lost.

None of our players strung a good four quarters together on Saturday. I chose Leon for his brilliant flashes that helped keep us in the game, and then for kicking the goal of the day.

[Presti35]

3 Sidebottom

2 Pendlebury

1 Beams

[ConBigWig]

Not one player was deserving of a vote today. It will be interesting to see who gets more than 1 vote at the copeland

Out best players were

Beams
Harry O

Sorry to say, the rest played well below expectations and were not worthy of a mention

sidebottom was very good IMO, possibly our worst player last week and i was rapt to see him stand up, i think the G suits the kid much more than the dome.

davis, davis had less than 10 disposals (i think) but was instrumental in the win, im giving him 2 votes, he stood up when we needed him, not a great game by leons standards though by any stretch.

pendles was ok too, nothing flash though, 1 vote from me.

3 sidebottom

2 leon

1 pendles.

beams unlucky, played well.
wellers also held his own i thought.

What's your reason for quoting me?

No Beams? interesting.