#17,#11 Dayne Beams

[rocketronnie]

[RudeBoy]

[rocketronnie]

[Magpietothemax]

It is clear that Beams is alienated from our club is some way. He and Harry are both in a similar boat (desiring to leave Collingwood) but Harry attended while Beams did not. Beams' apparent failure to feel any obligation to attend as a mark of respect towards his team mates and the club where he reached his current stature is likewise very disappointing. The reports of Beams' disrespectful responses to supporters on Instagram are likewise disheartening.
But Beams is a Collingwood Premiership player. This year he played with an energy and determination that distinguished him. So I think that invective and insults are misplaced. We simply have to treat the current situation with extreme pragmatism : we will ensure that as a result of Beams leaving, we are fully compensated. That is all. And, as Inkling suggests, there is every basis to believe that we will be. Beams will not wish to play at Collingwood next year, and if Brisbane cannot come up with an acceptable deal by Friday 5pm, other clubs will solicit him (because he is a gun) and will pay alot.

[Bob Sugar]

The more I think about it the more I want, I suggested we would/should settle for their first 2 DPs, but now I reckon we should hold out for pick 4 'and' one of their young stars (Aish-Rich), if they want to play hard ball we simply keep Beams and work on changing his mind.

It's clear now he won't be at Collingwood. It's no longer get him to Brisbane, it's anywhere but the Pies. If the Lions don't put up a good enough deal other clubs will come knocking and Beams is going to have to pick one of them. We are now in a great position and I'm certain we'll end up the winners in this deal.

So you're willing to concede that Buckley may have something to do with his departure?

[Wilko]

Can someone please explain why Beams has decided to alienate himself from the club
Surely he could just as easily be traded to Brisbane with his reputation intact
Why the angst ?

[Bob Sugar]

Can someone please explain why Beams has decided to alienate himself from the club
Surely he could just as easily be traded to Brisbane with his reputation intact
Why the angst ?

It's become clear he wants out for reasons other than family.

[Piesnchess]

Is it true Heater got arrested in Sydney, its a rumour doing the rounds.?? They reckon he was with beams, but beams was in Kew boozing on was he not ?

[Magpietothemax]

The more I think about it the more I want, I suggested we would/should settle for their first 2 DPs, but now I reckon we should hold out for pick 4 'and' one of their young stars (Aish-Rich), if they want to play hard ball we simply keep Beams and work on changing his mind.

It's clear now he won't be at Collingwood. It's no longer get him to Brisbane, it's anywhere but the Pies. If the Lions don't put up a good enough deal other clubs will come knocking and Beams is going to have to pick one of them. We are now in a great position and I'm certain we'll end up the winners in this deal.

So you're willing to concede that Buckley may have something to do with his departure?

Pure speculation and as such useless. Beside the point. We need to just focus on the current situation. Collingwood needs to be fully compensated for losing Beams. Stop. The reasons for Beams' desire to leave are at this stage unknown and therefore aren't relevant. Stop. When more information comes to light, maybe then can discuss. Stop.

[HAL]

Stop what?

[John Wren]

So you're willing to concede that Buckley may have something to do with his departure?

Pure speculation and as such useless. Beside the point. We need to just focus on the current situation. Collingwood needs to be fully compensated for losing Beams. Stop. The reasons for Beams' desire to leave are at this stage unknown and therefore aren't relevant. Stop. When more information comes to light, maybe then can discuss. Stop.

This is a forum numb nuts, speculating is what we do, now it's come to light that Martin has walked as well, that's 3 required players who have walked this year alone, we are a club in crisis.

no we're not.

[AN_Inkling]

The more I think about it the more I want, I suggested we would/should settle for their first 2 DPs, but now I reckon we should hold out for pick 4 'and' one of their young stars (Aish-Rich), if they want to play hard ball we simply keep Beams and work on changing his mind.

It's clear now he won't be at Collingwood. It's no longer get him to Brisbane, it's anywhere but the Pies. If the Lions don't put up a good enough deal other clubs will come knocking and Beams is going to have to pick one of them. We are now in a great position and I'm certain we'll end up the winners in this deal.

So you're willing to concede that Buckley may have something to do with his departure?

I've said all along that there's a problem with club/player relations, though I was more concerned about H's departure than Dayne's.

I wouldn't bring Martin into it though, that's just a player realising he wasn't up to it.

[Bob Sugar]

It's clear now he won't be at Collingwood. It's no longer get him to Brisbane, it's anywhere but the Pies. If the Lions don't put up a good enough deal other clubs will come knocking and Beams is going to have to pick one of them. We are now in a great position and I'm certain we'll end up the winners in this deal.

So you're willing to concede that Buckley may have something to do with his departure?

I've said all along that there's a problem with club/player relations, though I was more concerned about H's departure than Dayne's.

I wouldn't bring Martin into it though, that's just a player realising he wasn't up to it.

Don't be surprised if Martin plays for another AFL club next year.

[Bob Sugar]

Pure speculation and as such useless. Beside the point. We need to just focus on the current situation. Collingwood needs to be fully compensated for losing Beams. Stop. The reasons for Beams' desire to leave are at this stage unknown and therefore aren't relevant. Stop. When more information comes to light, maybe then can discuss. Stop.

This is a forum numb nuts, speculating is what we do, now it's come to light that Martin has walked as well, that's 3 required players who have walked this year alone, we are a club in crisis.

no we're not.

Yes we are, open your eyes man.

[rocketronnie]

Is it true Heater got arrested in Sydney, its a rumour doing the rounds.?? They reckon he was with beams, but beams was in Kew boozing on was he not ?

So many rumours and dodgy photographs doing the rounds - who knows what is true? I'm keeping an open mind on the issue until more info comes to light that is factual.